Cryptocurrency News
SHIB, DOGE get the cold shoulder as Lightchain AI with 21300% growth potential shines [btcmanager]
Market maker deals are quietly killing crypto projects [cointelegraph]


The right market maker can be a launchpad for a cryptocurrency project, opening the door to major exchanges and providing valuable liquidity to ensure a token is tradeable — but when the wrong incentives are baked into the deal, that market maker can become a wrecking ball.
One of the most popular and misunderstood offerings in the market-making world is the “loan option model.” This is when a project lends tokens to a market maker, who then uses them to create liquidity, improve price stability, and help secure listings at a cryptocurrency exchange. In reality, it has been a death sentence for many young projects.
But behind the scenes, a number of market makers is using the controversial token loan structure to enrich themselves at the expense of the very projects they’re meant to support. These deals, often framed as low-risk and high-reward, can crater token prices and leave fledgling crypto teams scrambling to recover.
“How it works is that market makers essentially loan tokens from a project at a certain price. In exchange for those tokens, they essentially promise to get them on big exchanges,” Ariel Givner, founder of Givner Law, told Cointelegraph. “If they don’t, then within a year, they repay them back at a higher price.”
What often happens is that market makers dump the loaned tokens. The initial sell-off tanks the price. Once the price has cratered, they buy the tokens back at a discount while keeping the profit.
Source: Ariel Givner
“I haven’t seen any token really benefit from these market makers,” Givner said. “I’m sure there are ethical ones, but the bigger ones I’ve seen just destroy charts.”
The market maker playbook
Firms like DWF Labs and Wintermute are some of the best-known market makers in the industry. Past governance proposals and contracts reviewed by Cointelegraph suggest that both firms proposed loan option models as part of their services — though Wintermute’s proposals call them “liquidity provision” services.
DWF Labs told Cointelegraph that it doesn’t rely on selling loaned assets to fund positions, as its balance sheet sufficiently supports its operations across exchanges without relying on liquidation risk.
“Selling loaned tokens upfront can damage a project’s liquidity — especially for small- to mid-cap tokens — and we’re not in the business of weakening ecosystems we invest in,” Andrei Grachev, managing partner of DWF Labs, said in a written response to Cointelegraph’s inquiry.
Related: Who’s really getting rich from the crypto bull run?
While DWF Labs emphasizes its commitment to ecosystem growth, some onchain analysts and industry observers have raised concerns about its trading practices.
Wintermute did not respond to Cointelegraph’s request for comment. But in a February X post, Wintermute CEO Evgeny Gaevoy published a series of posts to share some of the company’s operations with the community. He bluntly stated that Wintermute is not a charity but in the “business of making money by trading.”
Source: Evgeny Gaevoy
What happens after the market maker gets the tokens?
Jelle Buth, co-founder of market maker Enflux, told Cointelegraph that the loan option model is not unique to the well-known market makers like DWF and Wintermute and that there are other parties offering such “predatory deals.”
“I call it information arbitrage, where the market maker very clearly understands the pros and cons of the deals but is able to put it such that it’s a benefit. What they say is, ‘It’s a free market maker; you don’t have to put up the capital as a project; we provide the capital; we provide the market-making services,’” Buth said.
On the other end, many projects don’t fully understand the downsides of loan option deals and often learn the hard way that they weren’t built in their favor. Buth advises projects to measure whether loaning out their tokens would result in quality liquidity, which is measured by orders on the book and clearly outlined in the key performance indicators (KPIs) before committing to such deals. In many loan option deals, KPIs are often missing or vague when mentioned.
Cointelegraph reviewed the token performance of several projects that signed loan option deals with market makers, including some that worked with multiple firms at once. The outcome was the same in those examples: The projects were left worse off than when they started.
Six projects that worked with market makers under the loan option agreement tanked in price. Source: CoinGecko
“We’ve worked with projects that were screwed over after the loan model,” Kristiyan Slavev, co-founder of Web3 accelerator Delta3, told Cointelegraph.
“It’s exactly the same pattern. They give tokens, then they’re dumped. That’s pretty much what happens,” he said.
Not all market-maker deals end in disaster
The loan option model isn’t inherently harmful and can even benefit larger projects, but poor structuring can quickly turn it predatory, according to Buth.
A listings adviser who spoke to Cointelegraph on the condition of anonymity echoed the point, emphasizing that outcomes depend on how well a project manages its liquidity relationships. “I’ve seen a project with up to 11 market makers — about half using the loan model and the rest smaller firms,” they said. “The token didn’t dump because the team knew how to manage price and balance the risk across multiple partners.”
The adviser compared the model to borrowing from a bank: “Different banks offer different rates. No one runs a money-losing business unless they expect a return,” they said, adding that in crypto, the balance of power often favors those with more information. “It’s survival of the fittest.”
But some say the problem runs deeper. In a recent X post, Arthur Cheong, founder of DeFiance Capital, accused centralized exchanges of feigning ignorance of artificial pricing fueled by token projects and market makers working in lockstep. “Confidence in the altcoin market is eroding,” he wrote. “Absolutely bizarre that CEXs are turning an absolute blind eye to this.”
Still, the listings adviser maintained that not all exchanges are complicit: “The different tier exchanges are also taking really extreme actions against any predatory market makers, as well as projects that might look like they rugged. What exchanges do is they actually immediately lock up that account while they do their own investigation.”
“While there is a close working relationship, there is no influence between the market maker and the exchange of what gets listed. Every exchange would have their own due diligence processes. And to be frank, depending on the tier of the exchange, there is no way that there would be such an arrangement.”
Related: Crypto’s debanking problem persists despite new regulations
Rethinking market maker incentives
Some argue for a shift toward the “retainer model,” where a project pays a flat monthly fee to a market maker in exchange for clearly defined services rather than giving away tokens upfront. It’s less risky, though more expensive in the short term.
“The retainer model is much better because that way, market makers have incentives to work with the projects long term. In a loan model, you get, like, a one-year contract; they give you the tokens, you dump the tokens, and then one year after that, you return the tokens. Completely worthless,” Slavev said.
While the loan option model appears “predatory,” as Buth put it, Givner pointed out that in all these agreements, both parties involved agree to a secure contract.
“I don’t see a way that, at this current time, this is illegal,” Givner said. “If somebody wanted to look at manipulation, that’s one thing, but we’re not dealing with securities. So, that gray area is still there in crypto — [to] some extent the Wild West.”
The industry is becoming more aware of the risks tied to loan option models, especially as sudden token crashes increasingly raise red flags. In a now-deleted X post, onchain account Onchain Bureau claimed that a recent 90% drop in Mantra’s OM token was due to an expiring loan option deal with FalconX. Mantra denied the claim, clarifying that FalconX is a trading partner, not its market maker.
Edited LinkedIn copy of Onchain Bureau’s LinkedIn post. Source: Nahuel Angelone
But the episode highlights a growing trend: The loan option model has become a convenient scapegoat for token collapses — often with good reason. In a space where deal terms are hidden behind NDAs and roles like “market maker” or “trading partner” are fluid at best, it’s no surprise the public assumes the worst.
“We’re speaking up because we make money off the retainer model, but also, this [loan option model] is just killing projects too much,” Buth said.
Until transparency and accountability improve, the loan option model will remain one of crypto’s most misunderstood and abused deals.
Magazine: What do crypto market makers actually do? Liquidity or manipulation
Market maker deals are quietly killing crypto projects [cointelegraph]


The right market maker can be a launchpad for a cryptocurrency project, opening the door to major exchanges and providing valuable liquidity to ensure a token is tradeable — but when the wrong incentives are baked into the deal, that market maker can become a wrecking ball.
One of the most popular and misunderstood offerings in the market-making world is the “loan option model.” This is when a project lends tokens to a market maker, who then uses them to create liquidity, improve price stability, and help secure listings at a cryptocurrency exchange. In reality, it has been a death sentence for many young projects.
But behind the scenes, a number of market makers is using the controversial token loan structure to enrich themselves at the expense of the very projects they’re meant to support. These deals, often framed as low-risk and high-reward, can crater token prices and leave fledgling crypto teams scrambling to recover.
“How it works is that market makers essentially loan tokens from a project at a certain price. In exchange for those tokens, they essentially promise to get them on big exchanges,” Ariel Givner, founder of Givner Law, told Cointelegraph. “If they don’t, then within a year, they repay them back at a higher price.”
What often happens is that market makers dump the loaned tokens. The initial sell-off tanks the price. Once the price has cratered, they buy the tokens back at a discount while keeping the profit.
Source: Ariel Givner
“I haven’t seen any token really benefit from these market makers,” Givner said. “I’m sure there are ethical ones, but the bigger ones I’ve seen just destroy charts.”
The market maker playbook
Firms like DWF Labs and Wintermute are some of the best-known market makers in the industry. Past governance proposals and contracts reviewed by Cointelegraph suggest that both firms proposed loan option models as part of their services — though Wintermute’s proposals call them “liquidity provision” services.
DWF Labs told Cointelegraph that it doesn’t rely on selling loaned assets to fund positions, as its balance sheet sufficiently supports its operations across exchanges without relying on liquidation risk.
“Selling loaned tokens upfront can damage a project’s liquidity — especially for small- to mid-cap tokens — and we’re not in the business of weakening ecosystems we invest in,” Andrei Grachev, managing partner of DWF Labs, said in a written response to Cointelegraph’s inquiry.
Related: Who’s really getting rich from the crypto bull run?
While DWF Labs emphasizes its commitment to ecosystem growth, some onchain analysts and industry observers have raised concerns about its trading practices.
Wintermute did not respond to Cointelegraph’s request for comment. But in a February X post, Wintermute CEO Evgeny Gaevoy published a series of posts to share some of the company’s operations with the community. He bluntly stated that Wintermute is not a charity but in the “business of making money by trading.”
Source: Evgeny Gaevoy
What happens after the market maker gets the tokens?
Jelle Buth, co-founder of market maker Enflux, told Cointelegraph that the loan option model is not unique to the well-known market makers like DWF and Wintermute and that there are other parties offering such “predatory deals.”
“I call it information arbitrage, where the market maker very clearly understands the pros and cons of the deals but is able to put it such that it’s a benefit. What they say is, ‘It’s a free market maker; you don’t have to put up the capital as a project; we provide the capital; we provide the market-making services,’” Buth said.
On the other end, many projects don’t fully understand the downsides of loan option deals and often learn the hard way that they weren’t built in their favor. Buth advises projects to measure whether loaning out their tokens would result in quality liquidity, which is measured by orders on the book and clearly outlined in the key performance indicators (KPIs) before committing to such deals. In many loan option deals, KPIs are often missing or vague when mentioned.
Cointelegraph reviewed the token performance of several projects that signed loan option deals with market makers, including some that worked with multiple firms at once. The outcome was the same in those examples: The projects were left worse off than when they started.
Six projects that worked with market makers under the loan option agreement tanked in price. Source: CoinGecko
“We’ve worked with projects that were screwed over after the loan model,” Kristiyan Slavev, co-founder of Web3 accelerator Delta3, told Cointelegraph.
“It’s exactly the same pattern. They give tokens, then they’re dumped. That’s pretty much what happens,” he said.
Not all market-maker deals end in disaster
The loan option model isn’t inherently harmful and can even benefit larger projects, but poor structuring can quickly turn it predatory, according to Buth.
A listings adviser who spoke to Cointelegraph on the condition of anonymity echoed the point, emphasizing that outcomes depend on how well a project manages its liquidity relationships. “I’ve seen a project with up to 11 market makers — about half using the loan model and the rest smaller firms,” they said. “The token didn’t dump because the team knew how to manage price and balance the risk across multiple partners.”
The adviser compared the model to borrowing from a bank: “Different banks offer different rates. No one runs a money-losing business unless they expect a return,” they said, adding that in crypto, the balance of power often favors those with more information. “It’s survival of the fittest.”
But some say the problem runs deeper. In a recent X post, Arthur Cheong, founder of DeFiance Capital, accused centralized exchanges of feigning ignorance of artificial pricing fueled by token projects and market makers working in lockstep. “Confidence in the altcoin market is eroding,” he wrote. “Absolutely bizarre that CEXs are turning an absolute blind eye to this.”
Still, the listings adviser maintained that not all exchanges are complicit: “The different tier exchanges are also taking really extreme actions against any predatory market makers, as well as projects that might look like they rugged. What exchanges do is they actually immediately lock up that account while they do their own investigation.”
“While there is a close working relationship, there is no influence between the market maker and the exchange of what gets listed. Every exchange would have their own due diligence processes. And to be frank, depending on the tier of the exchange, there is no way that there would be such an arrangement.”
Related: Crypto’s debanking problem persists despite new regulations
Rethinking market maker incentives
Some argue for a shift toward the “retainer model,” where a project pays a flat monthly fee to a market maker in exchange for clearly defined services rather than giving away tokens upfront. It’s less risky, though more expensive in the short term.
“The retainer model is much better because that way, market makers have incentives to work with the projects long term. In a loan model, you get, like, a one-year contract; they give you the tokens, you dump the tokens, and then one year after that, you return the tokens. Completely worthless,” Slavev said.
While the loan option model appears “predatory,” as Buth put it, Givner pointed out that in all these agreements, both parties involved agree to a secure contract.
“I don’t see a way that, at this current time, this is illegal,” Givner said. “If somebody wanted to look at manipulation, that’s one thing, but we’re not dealing with securities. So, that gray area is still there in crypto — [to] some extent the Wild West.”
The industry is becoming more aware of the risks tied to loan option models, especially as sudden token crashes increasingly raise red flags. In a now-deleted X post, onchain account Onchain Bureau claimed that a recent 90% drop in Mantra’s OM token was due to an expiring loan option deal with FalconX. Mantra denied the claim, clarifying that FalconX is a trading partner, not its market maker.
Edited LinkedIn copy of Onchain Bureau’s LinkedIn post. Source: Nahuel Angelone
But the episode highlights a growing trend: The loan option model has become a convenient scapegoat for token collapses — often with good reason. In a space where deal terms are hidden behind NDAs and roles like “market maker” or “trading partner” are fluid at best, it’s no surprise the public assumes the worst.
“We’re speaking up because we make money off the retainer model, but also, this [loan option model] is just killing projects too much,” Buth said.
Until transparency and accountability improve, the loan option model will remain one of crypto’s most misunderstood and abused deals.
Magazine: What do crypto market makers actually do? Liquidity or manipulation
Panama City votes to approve crypto payments for public services [btcmanager]
Top 3 altcoins that are shining brighter than Bitcoin this week [btcmanager]
Ethereum faces $40m VC dump as ETH price slides below key support [btcmanager]
Bitcoin and gold show loss of confidence in fiat, says Galaxy CEO [btcmanager]
Stocks trim gains as China signals readiness for trade talks [btcmanager]
Emerging markets need boutique market-making to reach their full potential [cointelegraph]


Opinion by: Mārtiņš Beņķītis, co-founder and CEO of Gravity Team
As crypto adoption plateaus in some developed nations, emerging markets have led the charge for adoption. Southeast Asia, Africa and Latin America have become rapid growth centers, with new activity driven by limited banking options, local currency instability and growing smartphone use. The need for alternative finance in these regions is acute. While blockchain technology can deliver it, it certainly won’t be easy.
A significant hurdle in emerging crypto markets is market-making, where traditional approaches have struggled as a result of specific challenges, including limited infrastructure and economic instability. Standard market-making strategies often fail or are simply unable to account for these complexities. A new approach known as “boutique market-making” can unlock growth, providing tailored liquidity solutions that consider local factors like regional regulations, cultural nuance and specific pain points for each market.
This “boutique” approach will bring enormous benefits to the average person in emerging markets and, for the first time, create access to financial services and give them control over their economic outlook.
Providing liquidity in emerging markets is challenging
While the potential for growth in emerging crypto markets is clear to see, tapping into it is not. The path is fraught with challenges that require a specialized and nuanced approach. Here, standard market-making strategies are largely ineffective.
Consider trying to navigate the regulatory maze of a country where the rules keep changing and the economy is delicate and volatile. That’s the reality in Argentina. Stringent capital controls create a technical minefield for crypto transactions, requiring 24/7 monitoring and hyper-reactive strategies to ensure compliance. Why would any liquidity provider want to work with such uncertainty?
Then there’s the technological issue. Many local exchanges are built on outdated infrastructure with high latency and slippage. It’s far from the seamless APIs and lightning-fast execution of the world’s top platforms. It leads to traders and liquidity providers being discouraged from participating, resulting in thin order books, a persistent drought, and a vicious cycle of low liquidity and limited opportunity.
FX volatility further compounds the issue. Some fiat currencies experience wild fluctuations that deliver immediate conversion risks. Many local banking systems, aiming to protect their clients from this volatility, have implemented blanket bans on crypto-related transactions, causing settlement friction.
This cocktail of issues has pushed people away from centralized banking and right into the waiting arms of peer-to-peer trading, where direct transactions further fragment liquidity and make it hard for localized cryptocurrency exchanges to gain traction. These technical hurdles, however, can be overcome. They just require a contextually rich approach to market making, one that is acutely aware of every risk, issue, human need and cultural factor.
Why standardized solutions fail in emerging markets
Traditional market-making firms are used to standardized protocols, which makes it hard for them to adapt, leading to inadequate liquidity failures. This is particularly evident in regions like Argentina and Turkey, where local conditions demand bespoke solutions, despite Turkey having the highest crypto adoption rate in the world at 27.1%, followed by Argentina at 23.5%. These are well above the global crypto ownership rate estimated at 11.9%.
In Argentina, boutique firms can facilitate US dollar stablecoin flows to provide a crucial lifeline for those needing a stable alternative to the volatile peso and capital controls. Even considering this kind of service requires a deep understanding of local regulations and a proactive compliance approach.
In Turkey, price discrepancies between global and local platforms create considerable inefficiencies. Boutique market-makers stepped in to act as bridges, smoothing out inefficiencies and ensuring fairer prices for local traders.
Recent: Cryptocurrency investment should favor emerging markets
Take a look at Bolivia. Cryptocurrency was legalized in June 2024, with local crypto exchanges launching soon after but being starved of liquidity. Large firms didn’t want to touch them. Suddenly, when boutique market-makers stepped in, slippage was reduced, and prices stabilized, making trading more viable for investors of all sizes. The people won. The ability to build trust and forge lasting relationships with local communities and regulators is crucial. Hands must be shaken, and words must be kept.
Stable liquidity fuels opportunities
Boutique market makers work hard to deliver stable liquidity, in turn unlocking countless opportunities for people within emerging crypto markets. By providing consistent buy and sell orders, they reduce slippage and price volatility, creating a reliable environment for developers to build tools, platforms and decentralized applications tailored to local needs.
The stability provided by boutique market makers stems from their tailored strategies, using local knowledge, navigating regulatory mazes and bridging fragmented markets. This is unlike standardized approaches, which often falter on outdated tech or compliance hurdles. For users, this means accessible, liquid markets that support practical crypto use, from remittances to daily transactions, driving real-world adoption.
A boutique market making future
Emerging crypto markets stand at a tipping point. With their agility and local insight, boutique market-makers are the key to turning potential into action and opportunity. It’s time for stakeholders, exchanges, regulators and communities to properly rally behind these specialized players, nurturing ecosystems where innovation thrives and everyday users gain real access. The path ahead is about building a foundation for a decentralized economy that works for all. To get there, liquidity is essential.
Opinion by: Mārtiņš Beņķītis, co-founder and CEO of Gravity Team.
This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.